Castor Oil vs Vaseline for Lashes and Brows
The look you are after is glossy, tidy and well-groomed, and two things in two very different textures can get you there. One is a plant oil that pours; the other is a semi-solid ointment that most of us have in a drawer. Both are simple, so the choice comes down to how you like things to feel. We love both for different reasons, and we would never ask anyone to pick a side.
Organic Castor Oil
Cold-pressed, hexane-free castor oil, in sizes from a 0.5 oz sample to bulk drums.
From $13.99
Shop Organic Castor Oil →Meet the two
Petroleum jelly (Vaseline is the best-known brand) is a plain, firm ointment. The American Academy of Dermatology lists petrolatum among the ingredients to look for in ointments, which it says add more moisture to skin than lotions, and it suggests petroleum jelly for dry lips. Cleveland Clinic adds that the Academy recommends petroleum jelly for dry eyelids. That is a solid endorsement, and we think it deserves its reputation as a gentle, no-frills classic. We do not sell it, so a pharmacy is the place to find it.
Castor oil is a liquid, though a very slow one. A published review reports its viscosity at about 9 to 10 poise at 25 degrees Celsius, roughly a thousand times the viscosity of water, which is why it clings to a brush and gives a glossy finish. Our organic cold-pressed castor oil is a single ingredient, cold-pressed and hexane-free.
How each one sits on lashes and brows
Petroleum jelly goes on as a soft film and stays exactly where it is put. That makes it good for brow grooming, where you want hairs to lie in one direction and look neat. Castor oil is more cushiony and has a little slip, so it coats individual hairs and leaves a polished, conditioned look. For lashes, where a tiny amount is all you need, the liquid oil is easier to place with precision, while petroleum jelly can feel waxy if you use even slightly too much.
Texture also decides how much you will use. Petroleum jelly is firm enough that a rice-grain amount warmed between fingertips goes a long way, and it will not migrate. Castor oil can travel if you overload the brush, so the lightly loaded spoolie matters even more with oil. Either way, apply in the evening or when you will not be rubbing your eyes, and blot any excess with a tissue.
The spoolie makes the difference
With either one, the tool matters more than the product. Use a clean spoolie, loaded so lightly that it looks almost dry, and brush through the brows or lash line from the base outward. Wash the spoolie after each session and keep it for your own use. The same goes for any tool you put near your eyes: the FDA advises making sure that any instrument you place in the eye area is clean, and warns against sharing eye cosmetics. Our step-by-step posts on castor oil for eyelashes and castor oil for eyebrows walk through the technique.
One small tip from a lover of thick oils: keep each product in its own corner of the bathroom with its own clean tool, so the jelly never picks up oil and the oil never picks up lint. Tucked in a small pot, the jelly stays tidy. The oil, with its pale golden gleam, stays best in a bottle with a plain cap that you wipe after each use.
Eye-area care in one place
Keep any oil or ointment out of your eyes. If something irritates, stop using it, and if the irritation persists, see a doctor; for anything about your eyes themselves, an eye doctor is the right person. The skin there is delicate, so we favour a light touch, a patch test on your forearm first, and plain, fragrance-free products. If you want a gentler routine for the skin below the eyes, our post on castor oil under the eyes covers that.
Which one we would reach for
For brows you want to stay in place, petroleum jelly is hard to beat. For a softly glossy finish on lashes and brows alike, and for anyone who likes the feel of a rich oil, castor oil is our favourite. If castor feels too heavy, a little blending with a lighter oil makes it easier to handle; see how to dilute castor oil. Neither one is a miracle, and neither needs to be: both are simple ways to keep a groomed look. If your drawer already holds a jar of petroleum jelly, you are halfway there. Choose by feel: the one you actually enjoy putting on is the one you will keep using.
Organic Castor Oil
Cold-pressed, hexane-free organic castor oil, from a 0.5 oz sample to bulk sizes.
From $13.99
Shop Organic Castor Oil →Sources & Further Reading
- Dermatologists' top tips for relieving dry skin, American Academy of Dermatology
- Dry Eyelids: Possible Causes, Care & Treatments, Cleveland Clinic
- Eye Cosmetic Safety | FDA
- Castor oil (Ricinus communis): a review on the chemical composition and physicochemical properties, Food Science and Technology, 2021