Castor Oil vs Coconut Oil for Hair & Skin: Which to Use When

Coconut oil sits in its jar as a soft white solid and turns clear the moment it touches warm hands. Castor oil never sets: it pours like slow honey and clings wherever it lands. Put them side by side and it is tempting to ask which is better, but we think the more useful question is which one to reach for first.

Organic castor oil bottle

Organic Castor Oil

Cold-pressed, hexane-free castor oil, in sizes from a 0.5 oz sample to bulk drums.

From $13.99

Shop Organic Castor Oil →

Two different textures

Coconut oil has a melting point of about 78 degrees Fahrenheit, according to Harvard's Nutrition Source, and its saturated fat, which is nearly half lauric acid, gives it a firm texture at cool or room temperatures. In a warm kitchen it is a liquid; in a cool bathroom it is a scoop. Castor is mostly ricinoleic acid, up to about 90 percent of the oil, and is described as a viscous, pale yellow, nondrying oil. It stays liquid but never thin. Neither texture is a flaw. They are just built for different tasks.

Before the shampoo: coconut's moment

There is one piece of research we think deserves a mention because it is unusually clear. In a 2003 study, scientists compared mineral oil, sunflower oil and coconut oil on hair, and coconut was the only one of the three that reduced protein loss, in both undamaged and damaged hair. The study did not include castor, so we do not claim the same for it. What it does give us is a sensible reason to use coconut as a pre-wash oil: you put it on before shampooing, and the shampoo then does its normal job.

After the wash: castor's moment

Castor is better suited to the finishing steps. A few warmed drops smoothed over the ends give a glossy, softer-looking finish, and because it is so thick it makes a good sealing layer over damp hair. Our posts on castor oil for hair and how to use it cover amounts, and best oils for hair shows where each type of oil fits.

A use-by-job cheat sheet

JobOur pickWhy
Pre-wash hair oilingCoconutThe one with research behind it for protein loss
Sealing and shine on endsCastorThick, glossy, stays put
Body, right after a showerEitherCoconut spreads easily; castor is richer on dry spots
Face cleansing blendsCastorSmall share of a blend, see our oil cleansing post
LipsCastorAdds a glossy, cushioned feel

The body row is an honest tie. The American Academy of Dermatology says heavier products, such as ointments, are the most effective for dry skin and recommends applying moisturizer right after a shower. A rich oil follows that logic, so castor makes sense on elbows and heels, while coconut is the easier one to spread over a whole arm. More on both in castor oil for skin.

What about the face?

Popular comedogenicity charts rate coconut oil a 4 on a scale of 0 to 5 and castor oil 0 to 1, which is why coconut is often steered away from faces. Those scores come from rabbit-ear testing, and a dermatology study on the concept concluded that finished products with so-called comedogenic ingredients are not necessarily comedogenic. So treat the numbers as a rough guide, not a verdict. Our comedogenic rating post goes through it, and our oil cleansing guide shows the way castor usually appears on the face: as a small part of a blend. Everyone's skin is different, so try a new oil on a small spot first.

Our verdict

Keep both if you can. Coconut before the wash, castor after, and a little of whichever suits the spot for the body. If you want only one in your cabinet and your priority is gloss and a rich finish, castor is the one, and ours is a single ingredient: organic cold-pressed castor oil, with nothing added.

Whatever you choose, do a patch test first, keep oil out of your eyes, and ask a doctor or dermatologist about anything specific to you.

The best routine is usually the simplest one you will actually repeat, and with these two oils that can be as easy as one jar for before and one bottle for after.

Organic castor oil bottle

Organic Castor Oil

Cold-pressed, hexane-free organic castor oil, from a 0.5 oz sample to bulk sizes.

From $13.99

Shop Organic Castor Oil →

Sources & Further Reading

Important Disclaimer This content is for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The products and information discussed on this site are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before using castor oil or other natural products, especially if you are pregnant, nursing, taking medications, or have a medical condition.